Unfortunately the exact recipe is not longer known. My grandmother just mix this together without a written recipe. Because she lived in Germany I’m sure most of the ingredients were a little different, for example the used Herring. I’m not sure about the eggs, however I love food with eggs and some receipe I looked at had some. I know only for sure that she boiled the onions and used Miracle Whip had apples and pickles in the salad.

• 32 oz Vita Herring
• 1/2 small can Miracle Whip
• 2 medium apple
• Lemon juice
• 1 medium red onion
• 5 kosher dill pickle spares
• 4 hardboiled egg
• Celery
• Salt
• Pepper
• Mustard
• Dill

Wash the Herring and only use the fish pieces.

Cut everything else in small pieces. I added a little bit of lemon juice over the apple cubes to prevent discoloration.

Boil only the onion cubes in vinegar water.

Mix everything together.